My take on that result: ScarJo had the leaked nudes and the cover with Tom Ford and Keira Knightley. She was a known quantity. Also, the scenes are stark, clinical, and kinda dark. Daddario, meanwhile, came out of absolute nowhere with one of the hottest nude scenes in memory, showing absolutely everything in clear lighting during a scene that was highly charged. Swap women with scenes and ScarJo would have broken the Internet.