Anne Hathaway was only about 22 or 23 when she played the seductress in Havoc, and won the top spot on our poll of the Top Nude Scenes of 2005. She won that based on the usual formula – popular young actress gets naked for the first time – and not on the actual quality of the nudity. Five years later she truly earned the top spot (actually TIED for the top spot) among the Top Nude Scenes of 2010 with her performance in Love and Other Drugs.
Hathaway is not the only actress to top the polls twice. Christina Ricci also did it. Others came close. Anna Paquin had a first and a second in successive years, and Marisa Tomei took two consecutive second place finishes. Here is the master list of top ten finishers by year, with links to the individual polls, and here’s the search engine which only covers the poll results.
As for the “shirt” reference above, that’s me pulling a Dennis Miller. You have to be a certain age to get the obscure reference (see below):
