The automatic playoff bid for “outsiders”
The most interesting question this week involves one of the automatic bids. Boise State won this week, thus strengthening its grasp on the automatic spot reserved for one of the Gang of 6 teams. Its two nearest competitors, New Mexico and James Madison, both lost.
But Boise has not been impressive. They won their ninth straight game and secured the right to host the Pac-12 championship game, but Oregon State accumulated 506 yards and 41 points against them. After giving up 38 points to Colorado State the preceding week, Boise has now surrendered 79 points in two victories. It does not appear that defense is their forte.
Boise’s nearest rival is now … (wait for it) … Liberty! I can’t believe I’m typing this, but I think I would like to see Liberty sneak into the playoff. Talk about the ultimate underdog! If they get that 12th seed, their likely first round opponent, based on the current rankings, would be Notre Dame. I think a lot of people would watch that game. Including me.
For the record:
Here is how they stand in the SP+ rankings:
#19 Liberty
#22 Boise State
#23 New Mexico
#31 North Dakota State
#35 James Madison
#36 Memphis
Sagarin’s computations are not as supportive of Liberty’s case. His list is basically “Boise and some also-rans.”
#39 Boise State
#56 New Mexico
#64 Memphis
#68 Louisiana Tech
#70 Liberty
#71 Tulsa
#73 North Dakota State
The coaches’ poll also indicates a “Boise way or the highway” mentality:
#15 Boise State
#26 Liberty
#27 Memphis
#28 New Mexico
Of course, none of those lists are official playoff qualifiers, and the CFPC list doesn’t come out until Tuesday, but those lists indicate that Liberty is making a run at it!
In real games
Let’s call the top sixteen teams the playoff zone, consisting of those who would be in the playoff if the season ended today without conference championship games (top 11 plus Boise State), or those who are close enough to join that group if the teams above them falter. There was little movement within that group. None of the top ten teams lost. Numbers 12, 13, 15 and 16 also won, so #11 Kentucky and #14 Houston were the only losers in the playoff zone.
Undefeated #4 UCLA vs Illinois
UCLA stayed undefeated. Their offense wasn’t dazzling, but they played some great D, as they have all year. The Bruins held Illinois to 64 yards on the ground, and stopped the passing game as well. Illinois quarterbacks were just 16 for 37 and threw three INTs. UCLA has held seven straight opponents to 20 points or less and has now upped its season takeaway total to a nation-best 31.
UCLA drew the long straw on the schedule this year, with no game against Indiana, Ohio State or Iowa. They did get past Oregon, but it wasn’t easy (17-15). Their most likely opponent in the Big 10 championship game is Indiana.
Undefeated #2 Utah vs #23 Arizona
What a game. Neither team ever led by more than seven.
Arizona took a 39–33 lead with 3:13 remaining. Less than a minute later, Utah quarterback Devon Dampier connected with Creed Whittemore for a 70-yard touchdown, giving the Utes the go-ahead extra point with 2:35 left. That was plenty of time, but Arizona couldn’t cash the check on their final possession.
Utah is now 10–0 for the first time since its undefeated 2008 season. Arizona had forced two Dampier turnovers and converted both into touchdowns, but couldn’t finish the upset.
#6 Texas vs #21 LSU
The Longhorns were down 21-10 near the end of the third period. They eventually managed to pull it out by scoring a TD with two seconds on the clock. They converted three third downs on that last drive.
It was a messy game in which each QB threw three interceptions. With those three INTs and 11 penalties, LSU basically threw away a game in which they dominated the yardage comparison and stifled the Texas passing attack.
#8 Tennessee against Texas A&M
On the surface, it seems like there was no drama in the 22-7 Tennessee victory, but they had not scored a touchdown for three quarters and came into the final period with a tenuous 9-7 lead. Despite an impressive national ranking, Tennessee was only favored by 2.5, because Texas A&M has a good team and had home-field advantage. Good team? With a 1-6 conference record? You betcha! They are so good that they may be the biggest disappointment of 2026. They were ranked #8 in the pre-season AP poll, which everyone has now forgotten.
#11 Kentucky vs Florida
Was anyone surprised by the Kentucky loss? All of the objective measurements showed that they were dramatically overrated. Florida dominated the yardage 330-242, the time of possession 34-26, and had no turnovers.
#13 Wake Forest vs SMU
Last week, everyone (including me) gave Wake Forest a hard time about scheduling and destroying Merrimack. This week, they proved they could handle a competent opponent almost as easily.
SMU has a good squad. They came into that game 7-2, including 5-2 in ACC conference games. The SMU Mustangs were ranked 18th in the country by SP+, and they were playing at home. Despite that, Wake Forest totally took them apart. It was 42-0 at halftime. The Demon Deacons have now won their last six games by a combined score of 313-38!
Wake Forest has two possible roads to the post-season:
1) They could get in based on their ranking if some of the teams above them falter. Kentucky co-operated by losing, so WF will move up at least one spot.
2) They seem headed for the ACC championship game against Miami. Assuming they make it, an upset victory there would give them an automatic entry to the playoffs.
#14 Houston vs Colorado
That’s an embarrassing loss for Houston. They had flown close to the sun, but went full Icarus this week, blowing a 20-7 lead and losing to a team that came into the game 1-5 in conference play, and whose coach had his head beneath the guillotine.
Colorado beat #14 Houston 42–32, scoring five rushing touchdowns and recording its first victory over a top-15 opponent since 2007. Houston’s coach may have lost his playoff hopes while Colorado’s coach saved his job in the same game.
#17 South Carolina vs Arkansas
I suppose South Carolina might disappear from the Top 25 after this 34-6 debacle against a team that came into the game 3-6. South Carolina had four turnovers, Arkansas had none. That was pretty much the whole story.
#19 Ole Miss vs Oklahoma
The nationwide hiatus on air traffic caused a rare Sunday game as the Mississippi squad couldn’t get to Norman in time to play Oklahoma on Saturday. They should have stayed home. Mississippi now has four losses, but that is a result of playing the hardest schedule in the country (per Sagarin). Sagarin’s calculations indicate that Mississippi has played eight of the top 30 teams in the country!
Fun stuff farther down the rankings
Missouri State won in overtime on an 88-yard walk-off pick-six.
This is my favorite overlooked oddity of the weekend. Missouri State tied the game with a touchdown with 56 seconds left in regulation. Then, in overtime, defensive back Joel Boamah intercepted a pass and returned it 88 yards for the winning touchdown. The game ended immediately. Missouri State had already scored on a 15-yard interception return in the first quarter so they had two defensive touchdowns, one of them a walk-off in overtime. That’s considerably more entertaining than the average 27–21 game between two teams with losing records.
Merrimack rose from the sea and sank a conference champion!
Saturday brought good news and bad news for Monmouth, ranked #14 in the FCS. The good news: they clinched their conference championship. The bad news: they did that while losing to fucking Merrimack. Just one week after losing 77–0 to Wake Forest, the Merrimack Warriors upset nationally ranked FCS power Monmouth on a 39-yard field goal with 15 seconds left. Monmouth nevertheless clinched its first Coastal Athletic Association championship later that afternoon, when Campbell also lost.
California executed the worst fake field goal imaginable
Cal faced fourth-and-goal at the Virginia 4-yard line. Rather than kick the field goal, the Bears attempted a fake. Virginia safety Brandyn Hillman intercepted the pass and returned it 100 yards for a touchdown, the longest interception return in Virginia history. It didn’t matter much, Cal lost the game 36-7.


















